New York Personal Injury Lawyers
Call Today for a Free Consultation 212.577.9325 We Are Available 24/7

Audit Shows Safety Measures Not Fully Implemented After Two Crane Accidents

Audit Shows Safety Measures Not Fully Implemented After Two Crane Accidents

In an effort to make construction in New York safer following two Manhattan crane collapses in 2008 that killed a total of nine people, the Department of Buildings spent $5.8 million to hire private consultants and implement their recommendations, reported the New York Daily News (11.10.14).

The recommendations would have improved safety at construction worksites, as well as helped to protect pedestrians and others from potential construction accidents.

However, a recent audit by New York City Comptroller Scott M. Stringer‘s office found that a number of safety changes were not implemented even though safety would have been improved. Four years after the report was issued, only eight of the 65 recommendations were fully in place. Seventeen other recommendations were partially implemented and 18 were in progress.

Safety needs to be a top priority on any construction site.

CTL Engineers & Construction Technology Consultants (CTL) were the experts hired by the Department of Buildings to prepare the safety report after the two fatal crane accidents.

Safety is important on all construction projects for the protection of workers, for a safe work environment and, even, for controlling construction costs. Workers should not need to worry about their safety nor should pedestrians or residents walking by or living near a construction site. A dedicated commitment to safety also helps ensure project success and can significantly impact the bottom-line. Injuries cause high dollar losses. Implementing various safety procedures can help contractors and others avoid these costs.

In March 2008, a construction crane toppled and smashed through several residential buildings on E. 51st St., killing seven people and injuring 24. In May, a crane collapsed on E. 91st St., killing two construction workers and critically injuring one.

At the time the study was green-lighted, buildings officials said they would implement 49 of the 65 changes within two years, according to the audit.

According to the New York Daily News, some changes that were not put into place include, “requiring a technical adviser on a construction site during the assembly, climbing, and dismantling of a tower crane; requiring site safety personnel to report to the owner of a project instead of a contractor to avoid conflicts of interest, and mandating inspections of hoisting systems holding more than a ton.”

Department of Buildings officials disputed several of the findings and told investigators they had fully implemented 30 of the recommendations and partially implemented or were in progress on another 23, said the New York Daily News.

The New York Daily News story cited is “EXCLUSIVE: Only 8 of 65 safety fixes made after 2 deadly crane collapses despite millions spent, audit finds.”


  • “One of the best decisions I had ever made”

    - Joseph L.

  • “Mr. Perecman had my best interests at heart”

    - Anonymous

  • “He Made a difference for me and my family”

    - Jose J.

View More
  • Please enter your name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.